Jump to content
Snow?
Local
Radar
Cold?

strats

Members
  • Posts

    47
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by strats

  1. I think there couple of ways of dealing with this, both probably have their own issues.

    Solution 1 - create a cold themed thread

    pros 

    people can ramp away until their heart is content, regardless of the fact the models may only be showing a 6 hour toppler at best

    de-clutters the main thread

    things to consider 

    people will post where they feel most comfortable posting, probably where they feel they will contribute most and maybe where their post will be seen most 

    i also believe people like to interact with the various luminaries on the forum, so this may also influence where they post

    solution 

    zero tolerance moderation for he main thread. this will move/delete all off topic posts to the correct place, but people will probably still want to post in the main thread. So, if you keep moving/deleting posts you are encouraging people to either post in the correct place or post higher quality, less biased posts.

    Solution 2 - let the main thread become more partisan towards cold and open a technical/short range thread

    pros

    will probably keep the majority of posters in one place without too much confusion over where to post

    those who are happy to comment on the short term, technical basis (regardless of there preference) will have a place to post

    things to consider

    whilst this new thread will probably be a lot quieter in terms of posters, it may be a popular place for people to catch up on the short term prospects without having to wade through the usual cold biased posts

    what do we want to achieve? are we happy to go through this every winter, if so probably best to go with solution 2. or do we want to help people to increase the quality of their posts? if so, solution one is probably the way to go. I think either solution is fine, depending on what we want to achieve. I also think there's nothing wrong with letting the main thread become more cold biased, as long everyone feels they have a place to post without fear of being attacked for not agreeing with the majority. 

    just the thoughts of a long time lurker. 

    • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...